Beyond Natural Farming: A Holistic Farming Development Approach for Sustainable Agricultural Transformation in India
Indian agriculture is at a critical crossroads. The country must simultaneously ensure food and nutritional security for its growing population, improve farmers’ incomes, conserve natural resources, restore soil health, address climate change and maintain the economic viability of farming. These challenges cannot be addressed by promoting any single farming philosophy or production system, whether natural farming, organic farming or integrated farming, writes former Deputy Director General, UPCAR, Rajvir Singh Rathore.
Speaking before a large gathering of farmers, agricultural scientists and industry representatives at the India Today Group’s Bharat Agriculture Conference at Bharat Mandapam on 12th November 2026, PM Narendra Modi made a strong pitch for natural farming in order to save Mother Earth. While advocating the promotion of natural farming, the Prime Minister stated that a single cow could produce sufficient quantities of organic manure and other nutrient inputs to meet the nutritional requirements of crops grown on as much as 30 acres of farmland.
In this context, a theoretical calculation could be both interesting and eye-opening. Since the data from the 21st Livestock Census are yet to be released, the 20th Livestock Census (2019) has been used for this exercise. According to the 2019 Census, India’s total cattle population was approximately 193 million. However, considering the potentiality of indigenous cattle for preparation of various biodynamic products and biopesticides to improve soil health and sustainable agriculture, only the indigenous cattle population, estimated at around 141 million, has been considered. Against approximately 141 million hectares of net sown area and 225 million hectares of gross cropped area in India, the theoretical calculation suggests that indigenous cattle alone could potentially provide coverage equivalent to nearly 12 times the net sown area and 7 times the gross cropped area, assuming that one animal can effectively support 30 acres of farmland as claimed by the Prime Minister!
Such a significant claim certainly warrants rigorous scientific scrutiny and independent evaluation under different agro-climatic conditions. If validated, government-supported gaushalas could be systematically linked with adjoining agricultural lands to utilise cattle-based resources, improve soil health and reduce dependence on chemical fertilisers and pesticides. Furthermore, India’s extensive network of soil-testing laboratories could be effectively integrated into this approach to ensure soil-test-based nutrient management and balanced fertiliser recommendations. This would not only improve resource-use efficiency but also help reduce the substantial foreign exchange expenditure on imported fertilisers and agrochemicals, in the larger national interest.
Regarding the impact and efficacy of various biodynamic preparations, my personal experience has been somewhat less encouraging. I had the opportunity to interact with a New Zealand scientist regarded as a pioneer of biodynamic agriculture. Subsequently, while working with UPCAR, Lucknow, on the research components of two World Bank-supported projects namely; UPDASP and the Uttar Pradesh Sodic Land Reclamation Project, the results and practical effectiveness of such approaches were not particularly encouraging. Nevertheless, considering subsequent innovations and technological developments, the efficacy, consistency and economic viability of various biodynamic preparations and other products proposed under the Natural Farming Programme should be reassessed through scientifically designed trials and independent research agencies. Their promotion and large-scale adoption should be based on demonstrable evidence of agronomic effectiveness, economic viability and sustainability rather than assumptions or unverified claims even if made by the Prime Minister himself.
Indian agriculture is at a critical crossroads. The country must simultaneously ensure food and nutritional security for its growing population, improve farmers’ incomes, conserve natural resources, restore soil health, address climate change and maintain the economic viability of farming. These challenges cannot be addressed by promoting any single farming philosophy or production system, whether natural farming, organic farming or integrated farming. The Indian Council of Agricultural Research (ICAR), through its All-India Network on Natural Farming (AINNF), and the Government of India, through the National Mission on Natural Farming (NMNF), have undertaken important initiatives in this direction. However, the broader lessons from research, field demonstrations and implementation of these programmes need to inform future agricultural policies. Natural farming should be viewed as one of the available farming approaches rather than as a universal solution to India’s diverse agricultural challenges.
To reduce the use of chemicals and pesticides in agriculture, the Centre government has promoted two separate programmes. The Paramparagat Krishi Vikas Yojana (PKVY), launched in 2015, promotes organic farming, while the National Mission on Natural Farming (NMNF), approved in November 2024 with an outlay of Rs 2,481 crore, encourages chemical-free cultivation. Apart from these two major programmes, the Centre also runs the Mission Organic Value Chain Development for the North Eastern Region (MOVCDNER), which supports organic farming, certification, processing and marketing. According to the Agriculture Ministry’s 2026 parliamentary reply on NMNF, 18,786 natural farming clusters had been formed, covering 8.80 lakh hectares, with 18.19 lakh farmers enrolled as of March 5. The NMNF also provides incentive of Rs 4,000 per acre annually for two years, limited to one acre per farmer. In recent past, natural farming has attracted considerable policy attention in India, particularly because of its potential to reduce dependence on purchased agricultural inputs, encourage the use of locally available resources and promote ecological sustainability.
Lessons from ICAR’s All India Network on Natural Farming (AINNF) and the National Mission on Natural Farming
The AINNF initiative is particularly important because it provides an institutional framework for assessing natural farming under different agroclimatic conditions and cropping systems. The programme, initiated in 2020–21, has involved 20 cooperating centres across 16 states, covering eight major cropping systems. Its purpose includes evaluating natural farming practices and developing suitable packages of practices.
Some important lessons emerge from the available evidence;
One, natural farming is not universally suitable for every crop and region: Indian agriculture is characterised by enormous diversity in rainfall, soil types, irrigation facilities, farm sizes, cropping patterns and production requirements. A farming practice that performs satisfactorily in plantation crops or certain rainfed systems may not necessarily deliver comparable results in irrigated rice, wheat, sugarcane, pulses or other nutrient-intensive crops. Therefore, universal promotion of a fixed natural farming package is not scientifically justified.
Two, reduction in input costs does not automatically ensure higher productivity or profitability: Natural farming can reduce expenditure on purchased fertilisers and pesticides. However, the economic assessment must also account for labour requirements, preparation of bio-inputs, crop yields, market prices, transition costs and farmers’ opportunity costs. Evidence from natural farming studies indicates that lower cultivation costs can improve net returns in certain situations, but yield responses vary across crops and locations.
Three, soil health improvement requires a comprehensive resource-management strategy: Organic matter addition, crop residue recycling, green manuring, cover crops, crop diversification, balanced nutrient management, minimum soil disturbance and efficient water management are all important for improving soil health. These practices should be promoted on scientific merit, irrespective of whether they are classified as natural, organic or conventional farming.
Four, livestock integration and locally prepared bio-inputs have practical limitations: Livestock-based natural farming models can be beneficial, particularly for small and mixed farms. However, availability of adequate livestock, biomass, labour, water and raw materials differs considerably among farming households. A model that depends on cattle ownership or regular preparation of farm-made inputs cannot be prescribed indiscriminately to farmers who lack these resources.
Five, large-scale adoption requires stronger scientific validation and economic assessment: The NMNF appropriately emphasises farmer training, demonstrations, local bio-input resource centres, certification and market development. Its guidelines also recognise the need for location-specific packages and continuous handholding. Nevertheless, programme achievements in terms of farmers enrolled, clusters formed and area covered should not be treated as proof of improved productivity, profitability or environmental sustainability. These outcomes require independent, multi-year evaluation.
The central lesson is that India should promote the best combination of agricultural practices for each production situation rather than prescribe one particular farming system as the preferred national model.
Need for a Holistic Agriculture Development Approach
Since each farming system approach has some limitations, India needs a more comprehensive, science-based and location-specific Holistic Agriculture Development Approach that integrates productivity, profitability, sustainability, resource conservation and nutritional security. In this context, it is worth to mention that in the light of Prime Minister’s exhortation for doubling farmers’ income by 2022, a high-level committee of Governors had been constituted during the Governors’ Conference on 3-5 June 2018, under the Chairmanship of the then Governor of Uttar Pradesh for formulation of recommendations of Governors on “Approach to Agriculture- A Holistic overview”. In the report, various facets including (i) food security, (ii) health security, (iii) energy security, (water security), and (v) environmental security to prevent migration from rural areas to urban areas, and also to reduce the rural-urban divide were addressed and a comprehensive report was prepared and submitted to the Hon’ble President of India on 12 September 2018, with a copy to the all Governors, Lt. Governors, concerned ministries and head of the States for formulation of action plans.
A holistic approach should move beyond the debate between natural, organic, integrated and conventional farming. It should focus on achieving multiple agricultural objectives simultaneously through a judicious combination of traditional wisdom, modern agricultural science, appropriate technologies and locally suitable farming practices. Holistic farming considers the farm as an interconnected ecological and economic system. Its major advantages include:
- Food and nutritional security: Integrates cereals, pulses, oilseeds, millets, horticulture, livestock and fisheries to meet diverse food requirements.
- Comprehensive soil health management: Addresses physical, chemical and biological soil properties through organic matter management, balanced fertilisation, crop rotation and biological processes.
- Water resource conservation: Integrates crop planning, efficient irrigation, rainwater harvesting, watershed management and groundwater conservation.
- Efficient land utilisation: Promotes intercropping, multiple cropping, agroforestry and suitable enterprise integration, particularly for small and marginal farmers.
- Higher and stable farm income: Diversifies income sources, reduces production risks and promotes processing, value addition and market linkages.
- Climate resilience: Combines diversified cropping, resilient varieties, resource conservation, livestock integration and climate-smart technologies.
- Employment generation: Creates additional rural livelihood opportunities through dairy, poultry, fisheries, horticulture and agro-processing.
Importantly, holistic farming does not prescribe a single production technology. It allows the appropriate integration of natural farming, organic farming, integrated nutrient management, integrated pest management, conservation agriculture and modern scientific technologies according to regional requirements.
Way Forward
India should develop region-specific holistic farming strategies based on agroclimatic conditions, land and water availability, farm size and market opportunities.
Key priorities should include:
a) Integrating crop, livestock, horticulture and fisheries development.
b) Promoting natural farming wherever scientifically and economically suitable.
c) Ensuring balanced nutrient and water management.
d) Strengthening crop diversification and resource conservation.
e) Improving farm profitability through value addition and market integration.
f) Aligning agricultural missions through coordinated planning.
g) Developing comprehensive indicators to evaluate agricultural sustainability.
The future of Indian agriculture cannot depend on the promotion of any single production methodology. The country requires an agricultural development strategy that simultaneously addresses food security, nutritional security, farmers’ income, soil health, water conservation, climate resilience, biodiversity and rural livelihoods.
Holistic farming should therefore be considered the overarching strategic framework for sustainable agricultural transformation in India, with natural farming, organic farming, integrated farming systems and modern scientific technologies serving as complementary approaches within it. The central objective should be to develop farming systems that are not only environmentally sustainable but also productive, economically viable, nutritionally supportive and resilient to future challenges. India needs to move beyond the question of how to promote a particular method of farming towards a more fundamental question: How can we make the entire agricultural system sustainable, productive and profitable for present and future generation.
(Dr. Rajvir Singh Rathore is ex. Deputy Director General, UPCAR, Lucknow. Views expressed are personal.)



